Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe

If you’ve ever longed for a dessert that effortlessly glides between creamy, sweet, and nutty, then you’re about to fall in love with Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie. This luscious pie is a staple at Amish gatherings for a reason: it’s as comforting as it is indulgent, featuring layers of velvety filling, irresistible peanut butter crumbles, and a buttery graham cracker crust. If you haven’t tried making Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie before, let me assure you, each bite is a little celebration of rich peanut butter flavor and dreamy creaminess—an absolute must for pie enthusiasts and comfort food lovers alike.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Every great pie begins with simple ingredients that work harmoniously to create something special. Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie requires key components that bring together that signature texture and flavor, and each one plays its own pivotal role in making this dessert unforgettable.

• Pre-made graham cracker pie crust: This saves time while providing a crunchy, buttery contrast that anchors the creamy filling beautifully.
• Creamy peanut butter: Go for a classic, smooth peanut butter for crumbles that don’t overpower the delicate filling.
• Powdered sugar: This sweetens and lightens the crumb mixture, making it melt-in-your-mouth tender.
• Cream cheese (softened): Adds body, tang, and a luxurious creaminess to the filling.
• Granulated sugar: Infuses the cream cheese layer with balanced sweetness.
• Heavy cream: Whips airiness and volume into the filling, creating that fluffy, delicate mouthfeel.
• Vanilla extract: A small splash deepens the flavors with warmth and real vanilla aroma.
• Cold milk: Essential for activating the pudding mix and ensuring a perfectly smooth layer.
• Instant vanilla pudding mix (3.4 oz package): An easy shortcut for a stabilizing, silken middle that holds the pie together.

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Step 1: Make the Peanut Butter Crumble

Start by stirring together the peanut butter and powdered sugar in a bowl. Use a fork or pastry cutter and stop once you reach a crumbly, slightly sandy texture—these crumbles add not just a rich peanut flavor but also addictive little morsels of sweetness throughout the pie. If you mix too long, you’ll get a paste, so aim for loose, buttery crumbs.

Step 2: Make the Cream Cheese Filling

In a separate mixing bowl, beat the softened cream cheese with the granulated sugar until creamy. Next, pour in the heavy cream and a splash of vanilla extract. Beat again until the mixture turns light, fluffy, and doubled in volume—it should look like billowy frosting and feel almost mousse-like on your spoon. This airy layer is the soul of Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie.

Step 3: Prepare the Crust

Take half the peanut butter crumble and scatter it across the bottom of your graham cracker crust. Gently press it down to cover the base completely with a sweet nutty layer—this becomes the secret crunchy surprise beneath the creamy filling.

Step 4: Make the Pudding

Combine the cold milk and instant vanilla pudding mix in a clean bowl. Whisk vigorously for 2 to 3 minutes, watching as it thickens into a smooth and pudding-like consistency. This step ensures that the final pie is stable yet silky.

Step 5: Combine Layers

It’s magic time! Fold the chilled pudding into the whipped cream cheese mixture, gently swirling until the two become one unified, dreamy filling. Avoid overmixing so you don’t lose the volume and airiness you worked so hard to create.

Step 6: Fill the Crust

Pour your newly-combined creamy filling into the crust on top of the first peanut butter crumble layer. Use a spatula to spread it evenly, making sure the surface is smooth and inviting—think of it as the blank canvas for those final crumbles.

Step 7: Top and Chill

Finish by sprinkling the rest of the peanut butter crumbles over the pie, letting them fall like a sweet, nutty snow. Pop the pie into the refrigerator for a minimum of 4 hours, or overnight if you want the flavors and textures to fully develop. When you come back, you’ll unveil a sliceable, cloud-like pie that’s impossible to resist.

How to Serve Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Garnishes

While Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is joyfully rich all on its own, a touch of garnish is always welcome. Try a dollop of fresh whipped cream, a sprinkling of shaved chocolate, or a tiny drizzle of melted peanut butter. Each accent brings its own personality, turning every slice into something worthy of a special occasion (or just because it’s Thursday).

Side Dishes

Balance all that creaminess with a fresh fruit salad—think berries or orange segments for a bright, tangy note. A scoop of vanilla ice cream alongside the pie is never out of place either, especially if you want to serve an extra dreamy dessert plate at your next family meal.

Creative Ways to Present

Dress up mini tart shells for individual servings—adorable for parties! Or, layer cubes of the pie in parfait glasses with extra whipped cream and a sprinkle of chopped roasted peanuts for a playful twist. You can even cut small squares for a dessert buffet or picnic, showing off those signature layers of Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie in every bite.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Cover any remaining slices tightly with plastic wrap or store in an airtight container in the fridge. Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie keeps beautifully for up to 3 days—just be sure it’s well-sealed to prevent it from drying out or absorbing refrigerator odors.

Freezing

If you want to get ahead, you can freeze the whole pie (or individual slices) by wrapping well in plastic and foil. When ready to enjoy, thaw overnight in the refrigerator—the texture will stay creamy and the crumbles will hold up better than you’d expect! Just avoid freezing garnishes like whipped cream for best results.

Reheating

Thankfully, this pie is best served chilled, so there’s no need to reheat. Let frozen slices thaw in the fridge, and they’ll be as luscious as the day you made them. Enjoy straight from the fridge for the ultimate smooth and refreshing treat!

FAQs

Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy in Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Absolutely! Crunchy peanut butter will add a little extra texture and peanutty depth to the crumbles. Just be aware that the pie will have small peanut bits throughout, which some people adore. Creamy is classic, but don’t be afraid to put your own spin on it!

What’s the best way to get smooth cream cheese filling without lumps?

Make sure your cream cheese is fully softened to room temperature before beating and use a hand mixer or stand mixer for even, lump-free blending. For extra assurance, you can sift the granulated sugar before adding—it’s a little trick that makes everything super silky.

Can I make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie ahead of time?

Yes! In fact, the flavors and texture only improve after sitting in the fridge for a few hours or overnight. Assemble the entire pie a day ahead, cover well, and you’re ready for hassle-free dessert the next day.

Is there a gluten-free option for the crust?

Definitely. Simply swap in a gluten-free graham cracker crust from the store, or make your own by crushing gluten-free graham crackers and mixing with melted butter. The filling is naturally gluten-free, so just switch the crust and you’re set!

How do I keep the peanut butter crumble from turning into a paste?

Mix the peanut butter and powdered sugar just until combined and crumbly, using either two forks or a pastry cutter. If you overmix or use a stand mixer, it’ll morph into a paste, so keep it light and crumbly for the best texture.

Final Thoughts

If you’re searching for a dessert that truly impresses without a lot of fuss, Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is your answer. This recipe is not only easy and approachable, but also delivers outrageously delicious results with every single bite. It’s the kind of homemade treat you’ll be proud to serve at gatherings or tuck away for a special weeknight surprise—give it a try, and don’t be surprised if it disappears in record time!

Print